Rule One: The Doctor Lies

 In “The Girl Who Waited,” Rory and Amy were compelling and wonderful, the directing was flawless, the acting was pitch-perfect, and the timey-wimey plot made absolutely 0 sense (I still don’t get how you sit here for a day and the people on the other side live out their lives of one day, since they’re infected). It was certainly a wonderful episode on every level. But what I found most interesting was that it was one of the most brutal yet explorations of Rule One.

The Doctor’s rampant fibbing was certainly present pre-eleven, but I don’t remember it being anywhere near as pronounced as it is now. It seems that the Doctor is lying left and right these days, and when called on it he tends to just shout “That was a clever lie!” When he lies, it is usually to his companions, be it short term like the fellow in The Lodger or long term like Amy and Rory. Usually, these lies are with the best of intentions—to reassure them, to make them back off so he can do something dangerous without them, or in the best of his lies, to give them the strength to do what they need to do.

These lies are necessary, and often do what they need to do. The world gets saved, most everybody lives. But in “The Girl Who Waited,” the Doctor lied purely to deceive his companions. He knew from the beginning that he could not take both Amys, and he led on the old Amy, failing her yet again.

Did the Doctor make the right call? He knew he couldn’t really bring both Amys, but by lying he was able to save the young Amy. He made a difficult call: that the Amy he knew was more important than the Amy he didn’t know.  If he hadn’t lied, the Amy who would have lived would have been the old Amy. The Amy he had failed yet again.

It was an essentially selfish act, but not in an immoral way. He chose the Amy he knew, and he did what Rory and Amy couldn’t do. In “Amy’s Choice,” he told them that the evil-feeding pollen “Would have starved to death in a second on the evil inside you; I choose my friends carefully.” These friends keep him human, they keep him good. And we believe that the Doctor is good, because we, the viewers, love the Doctor just as much as his companions.

But every once in a while, we get these painful, heartbreaking reminders that the Doctor is much older and much less human than we usually notice. He is the one who can make the choices no one else can stand to make. They pain him greatly, as we saw when he locked old Amy out of the Tardis, but he makes them nonetheless. And he always will. And in spite of these moments when he seem so alien and cold, we will always love him, because he is just too damn wonderful.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s